Glued forever: incomplete dispersion hampers POM-MAOM fractionation in soils with high SOC and metal (hydr)oxide content

- 335049
Oral communications
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Accurate separation of particulate (POM) and mineral-associated (MAOM) organic matter is fundamental for understanding soil fertility, nutrient cycling, and soil health. Size-based fractionation after chemical dispersion with sodium hexametaphosphate is widely used, yet its reliability depends on complete breakdown of soil aggregates. Using a diverse set of 38 soils, we evaluated how soil properties influence dispersion efficiency and, consequently, the accuracy of POM–MAOM fractionation. Completeness of dispersion was assessed by quantifying fine particles (<50 µm) retained in the coarse fraction (>50 µm) using laser diffraction. Across soils, incomplete dispersion was strongly associated with higher contents of SOC and nanocrystalline Al and Fe (hydr)oxides, and was further modulated by texture. As a result, substantial amounts of MAOM were erroneously retained in the coarse fraction. This led to overestimation of POM by up to 217% and underestimation of MAOM by up to 53%, with direct implications for interpretations of SOM stabilization mechanisms and soil fertility assessments. We further identified the residual moisture content of soils dried at 40 °C as a low-cost, practical indicator of dispersion risk, except in soils enriched in exchangeable Na and/or Mg. Our findings highlight that incomplete dispersion is a systematic yet often overlooked source of error in SOM fractionation, particularly in SOC- and metal-oxide-rich soils. Routine evaluation and reporting of dispersion completeness will enhance the reliability of SOM pools as indicators of soil health and nutrient cycling, while guiding methodological improvements that avoid fragmentation of POM.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Wageningen University & Research
  • 2 Louis Bolk Instituut
  • 3 Netherlands Institute of Ecology
  • 4 International Center for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) AND Wageningen University & Research
Track
  • Advanced methodologies for SOM assessment
Keywords
soil organic carbon
size fractionation
method evaluation
SHMP
soil texture