Researching educational (In)Equity in Primary Education – Social Practices and Institutional Structures in the Light of current dynamics

- 213225
WERA Invitational Symposia
Favoritar este trabalho
Como citar esse trabalho?
Resumo
The IRN focusses on international research on primary education in relation to worldwide requirements for high-quality inclusive education and educational equity (United Nations, 2015, goals 4 & 10). The aim is to gather innovative research perspectives on the peculiarities of education at primary school level and to intensify discourses on its specific meaning related to aspects of educational (in)equity within differently structured education systems. Our starting points for the proposed symposium are the (in)equity-related current dynamics in international political and scientific discourses and their processing at the primary school level. On that basis we will focus on the following two key aspects: (1) Social Practices and Actors in primary school education: Addressing the first aspect, paper one will deal with the perspective of primary school children on achievement and reflect on the findings from the perspective of the difficult relationship between meritocracy and inclusion. With paper two the role of teachers is addressed, foremost regarding their roles and interactions in the construction of language-related discrimination in class; (2) Institutions and structure: With the third paper institutional structures are taken into view. This paper is a comparative document analysis focusing on standards and regulations for pre-service teachers in Canada, Germany and Brazil. Inclusion and Meritocracy? Primary School Children's Perspectives on Achievement (Simone Seitz, Sara Baroni, Petra Auer & Alessandra Imperio) The qualitative study “CRISP” (Children’s Perspectives on Performance in Primary schools; 2022–2024) understands achievement as socially constructed – particularly through social practices of assessment (Seitz, Imperio & Auer, 2023), which are intrinsically linked to the production of differences within (inclusive) learning groups. Aiming to gain deeper insights into children’s perspectives on achievement, achievement differences and assessment in primary school classrooms within the Italian inclusive education system, narrative interviews with 35 third-grade primary school children in Italy were conducted. The children’s collective social sense-making was reconstructed using the working steps of the Documentary Method (Bohnsack, Pfaff & Weller, 2010). The contribution will present the theoretical framework, the methodological design, and the overall findings, the latter to be discussed in relation to the significance and positioning of achievement within the institutional framework of an inclusive education system (Seitz et al., 2024) and under the dispositive of meritocracy as mediated by current policies (Ministero dell’Istruzione e del Merito, 2025). The Role of Teachers in the Construction of Inequity in multilingual Classrooms (Sarah Désirée Lange, Zahia Alhallak & Maike Lüssenhop) Primary school teachers in Germany find themselves in an antinomic tension between multilingual learning backgrounds on the one hand and monolingual school and teaching practices on the other. Current research shows that linguistic discrimination is effective in schools. From a perspective of power and differentiation, as well as linguicism, language can reproduce social hierarchies in various ways (Cunningham, 2019). In this context, a case study was conducted with primary school teachers in Germany talking about multilingual children to shed light on linguistic constructions of inequity (cf. Lange, Alhallak & Plohmer, 2024). The interviews (N=43) were analyzed from a difference-sensitive perspective. The results show three constructions of inequity: deficit constructions in relation to multilingual children as a barrier to ‘successful’ teaching and learning, differences in relation to the construction of multilingual children as processes of othering, and group-related constructions in relation to children, who supposedly speak the same language. Based on these findings, implications for promoting needs- and resource-based teaching approaches in primary school teaching are discussed. Institutional Structures for Promoting Multilingualism in Primary Schools as an Asset (Miriam Siggelkow & Roswita Dressler Rarely have we had so many cultures and languages come together as currently in primary schools globally (Zaidi et al., 2023). Pre-service teachers (PST) working in culturally and linguistically diverse classrooms may perpetuate inequities, if they do not view multilingualism as an asset (Prasad, 2023). Therefore we focus on how multilingualism is addressed in PST education in Canada, Germany and Brazil. We conducted a comparative document analysis of one key document from each country that outlines requirements for university PST education (Bowen, 2009). Preliminary results reveal a deficit perspective toward multilingualism in the German Standards für die Lehrerbildung (Standards for Teacher Education) and strengths-based perspectives in Alberta, Canada’s Teacher Quality Standards, and Brazil’s Base Nacional Comun de Formação de Professores (National Common Base for Teacher Training). The differences and similarities the three countries’ documents provide theoretical and practical insights into PST educational standards and curricula. Keywords: inequity, meritocracy, linguicism, primary school, teachers’ professionalism, children’s views References Bohnsack, R., Pfaff, N., & Weller, W. (Eds.). (2010). Qualitative Analysis and Documentary Method in International Educational Research. Barbara Budrich. Bowen, G. A. (2009). Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal, 9(2), 27–40. https://doi.org/10.3316/QRJ0902027 Cunningham, C. (2019). ‘The inappropriateness of language’: discourses of power and control over languages beyond English in primary schools. Language and Education, 33(4), 285-301. Kyngäs, H. (2020). Qualitative research and content analysis. In H. Kyngäs, K. Mikkonen, & M. Kääriäinen (Eds.), The Application of Content Analysis in Nursing Science Research. Springer eBooks Medicine (1st ed. 2020, pp. 3–11). Springer. Lange, S. D., Alhallak, Z., & Plohmer, A. (2024). „Sie dürfen sich nicht auf ihrer Muttersprache unterhalten und das finde ich tatsächlich auch gut“. Zeitschrift für Grundschulforschung, 1-16. Ministero dell’Istruzione e del Merito (2025). Missione e funzione. https://www.mim.gov.it Seitz, S., Imperio, A. & Auer, P. (2023). “Otherwise, there would be no point in going to school”: Children’s views on assessment. Education sciences 13 (8), 828. Seitz, S., Kaiser, M., Auer, P. & Bellacicco, R. (2024). Giftedness, achievement, and inclusion: A discourse analysis. L'Integrazione Scolastica e Sociale 23(1), pp 8-32. DOI: 10.14605/ISS2312401 Prasad, G. (2023). Be(com)ing multilingual allies and activists. In R. Zaidi, U. Boz, & E. Moreau (Eds.), Transcultural pedagogies for multilingual classrooms (pp. 53–72). Multilingual Matters. United Nations (2015). Transforming our world: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. United Nations. Zaidi, R., Boz, U., & Moreau, E. (Eds.). (2023). Transcultural pedagogies for multilingual classrooms: Responding to changing realities in theory and practice. Multilingual Matters.

Compartilhe suas ideias ou dúvidas com os autores!

Sabia que o maior estímulo no desenvolvimento científico e cultural é a curiosidade? Deixe seus questionamentos ou sugestões para o autor!

Faça login para interagir

Tem uma dúvida ou sugestão? Compartilhe seu feedback com os autores!

Eixo Temático
  • Curriculum Research
Palavras-chave
inequity, meritocracy, linguicism, primary school, teachers’ professionalism, children’s views