Deconstructing models of parental involvement as an inclusive strategy to address inequalities in education

- 212742
Paper-Thematic
Favoritar este trabalho
Como citar esse trabalho?
Resumo

This systematic review argues that current models of parental involvement at Foundation Phase level often perpetuate existing socio-economic inequalities because they centre on middle-class norms, inadvertently marginalising some learners. These models focus on narrow definitions of good parenting, such as parents offering extensive volunteer work and frequent school visits. Admittedly, these are part of good parental involvement in their children’s school work, however, they place undue burden on families from marginalised communities. Marginalised communities in this context are affected by several markers, which include child-headed households, single-parent households, those experiencing poverty, and those living with disabilities. The current parental involvement models, frequently framed around the nuclear family, often reinforce existing power dynamics, marginalise families coming from diverse backgrounds, consequently, contributing to the achievement gap (Ishimaru, 2019). There is a lot of emphasis on specific forms of engagements that excludes families who may face challenges to participation due to transportation limitations, work schedules, language barriers, or certain disabilities. As a result, parents from marginalised communities are engulfed with feelings of inadequacy and guilt because they cannot engage in specific ways, further exacerbating existing disparities in educational outcomes. However, this does not mean that families from marginalised communities are not involved in their children’s schooling, rather they are involved in ways that are not recognised by current models. Current parental involvement models often fail to recognize the valuable forms of engagement that families from marginalised backgrounds already provide. These include the support parents provide toward their children's learning at home through cultural practices, community connections and storytelling. This systematic review argues for a pedagogical shift towards more equitable and inclusive models of family-school collaborations (Teemant, 2021). The parental involvement models should centre on cultural assets and family strengths, address the roots or underlying causes of educational inequalities such as racism and poverty. This, potentially, leads to building effective partnerships based on trust and mutual respect, and empowerment of marginalised families in advocating for their children's needs (Davidson & Case, 2018). By moving beyond traditional models of parental involvement and embracing a more equitable and inclusive approach, schools can create more supportive learning environments, not just for most, but for all learners, thus, contributing to a more just and equitable society (Küçüksüleymanoglu, 2025). By challenging existing assumptions and advocating for more equitable and inclusive models, this review can contribute to creating a more just and equitable educational system for all learners. A comprehensive search strategy was employed to identify relevant studies published in books, peer-reviewed journals, and conference proceedings across major academic databases. These included Scopus, ERIC, JSTOR, Web of Science, and Google Scholar, and utilisation of a combination of keywords such as family engagement, parental involvement, social justice, educational inequalities, and diversity. Grey literature, such as policy documents, and government reports were also be explored. Studies that employed quantitative, qualitative, or mixed methods designs were included. Additionally, studies that focus on the experiences and perspectives of diverse families, and explicitly address issues of equity, diversity, and inclusion were included. Studies that are solely theoretical, focus exclusively on middle-class or homogenous populations, or are published in non-peer-reviewed sources were excluded. Relevant data were extracted from each included study using thematic analysis to identify key themes and patterns. The quality of the included studies was critically appraised using established quality assessment tools. This review adheres to ethical guidelines for research, including respect for participant confidentiality and privacy. This methodology provided a robust framework for conducting a comprehensive and rigorous systematic review of the literature on parental involvement and its impact on educational inequalities, ensuring a focus on high-quality review that addresses the critical issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion. This study found that current models of parental involvement unintentionally perpetuate educational inequalities. By focusing on middle-class norms and prioritising those activities only accessible to these families, these models can create significant hurdles for families facing poverty, child-headed families, single-parent households, disabilities, or language barriers. This exclusion, coupled with failure to acknowledge diverse forms of parental support, such as cultural practices and home-based learning, can contribute to feelings of inadequacy and ultimately exacerbate the achievement gap. To address these issues, this study recommends shifting towards more inclusive models that: i) broaden the definition of parental involvement, ii) build genuine partnerships with families, iii) address systemic barriers, and iv) empower all families to advocate for their children's needs. By implementing these recommendations, schools can create more equitable and inclusive learning environments for not just most, but all learners.

Compartilhe suas ideias ou dúvidas com os autores!

Sabia que o maior estímulo no desenvolvimento científico e cultural é a curiosidade? Deixe seus questionamentos ou sugestões para o autor!

Faça login para interagir

Tem uma dúvida ou sugestão? Compartilhe seu feedback com os autores!

Eixo Temático
  • Thematic Area 11: GLOBAL FINDINGS ON VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING
Palavras-chave
Achievement gap
cultural capital
equity
family-school partnerships
social justice