Beyond 5,000 inhabitants: demographic gradient and the limits of the population criterion in Constitutional Amendment Proposal 188/2019

- 335424
Póster - Paso 3
Favoritar este trabajo
¿Cómo citar este artículo?
Resúmenes

The post-1988 proliferation of small municipalities in Brazil has kept the fiscal, administrative, and demographic viability of local governments at the center of the debate on the federative pact. Constitu tional Amendment Proposal No. 188/2019 established two criteria for incorporating small municipalities into neighboring units: a demographic criterion, having up to 5,000 inhabitants, and a fiscal criterion, own-source revenue below 10% of total revenue. The legislative debate and subsequent literature focused almost exclusively on the fiscal criterion, without examining whether the demographic cutoff corresponds to a substantive boundary among small Brazilian municipalities or merely to an arbitrary point within a continuous gradient of vulnerability. This article evaluates this question by combining a longitudinal comparison of demographic indicators by population-size stratum across four Demographic Censuses (1991, 2000, 2010, and 2022) with a detailed cross-sectional characterization of the 2022 Census, qualified by measures of position, dispersion, and effect size. The results show that the municipal hierarchy combines administrative fragmentation and population concentration: in 2022, municipalities with up to 20,000 inhabitants accounted for 69.32% of municipal units and only 15.77% of the national popula tion, with the PEC cutoff concentrating the highest levels of aging, old-age dependency, and relative masculinization among all strata. The cross-sectional comparison reveals a dual regime: differences of moderate magnitude relative to the immediately higher population stratum, but large differences relative to larger municipalities. The PEC cutoff, however, presents the highest coefficients of variation in the entire municipal hierarchy, revealing strong internal heterogeneity: extremely aged and rural municipalities coexist with municipalities whose demographic profile is closer to the Small I stratum than to that of their own peers below 5,000 inhabitants. It is concluded that the demographic criterion of the PEC does not isolate a distinct category, but occupies the extreme of a continuous gradient of vulnerability, a finding that, together with the absence of a systematic examination of this dimension in the legislative debate, qualifies the limits of the fiscal criterion as the exclusive basis for policies of federative reorganization.

¡Comparte tus ideas o preguntas con los autores!

¿Sabías que el mayor estímulo en el desarrollo científico y cultural es la curiosidad? ¡Deje sus preguntas o sugerencias al autor!

Inicia sesión para interactuar

¿Tiene alguna pregunta o sugerencia? ¡Comparte tus comentarios con los autores!

Instituciones
  • 1 Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo
  • 2 Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP)
Eje Temático
  • 3.3 Migración interna en América Latina y el Caribe
Palabras Clave
Small municipalities
Demographic gradient
Population aging
Spatial redistribution
Federative pact