The Promises and Limits of Dialogue: Negotiating Professional Practices through Dialogic Research Design

- 333681
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Introduction. In times of systemic transformations, public service professionals require skills to reconcile polarized stances, to negotiate contested values, and to uphold human rights, justice and inclusion. Dialogue can be seen as underlying epistemological, methodological and practical tool to address multiple voices and perspectives. Drawn from dialogic scholarship (Bakhtin, Buber, Gadamer, Rogers, Bohm), the conceptual framework also integrates dimensions of dialogic engagement — mutuality, propinquity, empathy, risk-taking, and commitment (Kent & Taylor, 2002, 2014, 2021). 

Goals & method. Based on dialogic research design (Kristensen, 2020; Poopuu, 2020), this paper explores how professionals in various fields (media & communication, child welfare, inclusive education, prison social work, and public service) negotiate ongoing changes, tensions, and contradictions through dialogic engagement when addressing human rights, social inclusion, resilience, and empowerment. In Lithuania, we conducted 12 focus groups (N=62), using case vignettes (Barter & Renold, 2000; Martin et al., 2025). Case vignettes explore participants' views, experiences, interpretative resources related to the situation (Törrönen, 2018). Cases presented in vignettes depict tensions and ethical dilemmas arising from paradigm shifts.  Thematic analysis (Clarke & Braun, 2006) was applied to identify general patterns of meaning. This qualitative research study was conducted within the framework of Horizon Europe project Diacomet. 

Results. Focus group discussions revealed the dimensions of dialogic engagement and institutional/structural constraints, resulting in incomplete and fragile forms of dialogue. Discussions focused on disruptive trends and tensions like social/political polarization, power asymmetries and inequalities. Propinquity and risk-taking - both significant features of dialogue - are restricted by institutional regulations and practices, insufficient resources, and uncertainty avoidance cultures.  

Conclusions. Our study shows how dialogic engagement is a contested practice within these professional fields addressing human rights, stigma, and inclusion. Findings contribute to dialogic theory by demonstrating how ideals of dialogue are negotiated and constrained, sometimes in the form of dialogic loops. 

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Vytautas Magnus University
Track
  • 3. Qualitative Research in Social Science
Keywords
dialogic engagement
public service professionals
dialogic research design
focus group discussions
case vignettes