Grounded Theory in Vienna: On Saturation as Verification and the Problem of Induction

- 334037
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Introduction. Since the publication of Glaser and Strauss’s seminal work, qualitative researchers have used the concept of saturation as a mark of rigor. And while the concept has been defined and applied in multiple ways since, most definitions and applications rest on a single, fundamental premise: that there is a knowable limit one can reach to determine when data collection is sufficient.

Goals and Methods. Synthesizing previous critiques of saturation by qualitative researchers, I analyse to what extent saturation suffers from the same logical problem that plagued positivism’s reliance on verificationism, namely, the problem of induction. The problem of induction refers to the logical impossibility of knowing when a particular number of observations is sufficient to justify inferences about future observations. The popular illustration of this problem is this: when “all examined swans have been white,” we may infer to the theory “all swans are white,” but it takes only one black swan to render that theory false. Thus, no number of positive observations is sufficient to establish a logical basis for inference.

Results. Though not identically, saturation and verificationism seem to share similar features of the problem of induction: (1) positive observations are collected until the nth observation is reached; (2) the researcher is often assumed to be in a position of special knowledge regarding the nth observation (i.e., the researcher determines how many cases of X is sufficient to determine n); and (3) those n observations are almost always used to justify an inference. However, key differences between the two exist. For instance, to positivists, the object of inductive inference was the veracity of a scientific theory while to qualitative researchers it may be a theoretical category, a theme, or a data set.

Conclusions. I conclude with epistemological, methodological, and political-economic implications for saturation. 

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Lakehead University
Track
  • 3. Qualitative Research in Social Science
Keywords
Saturation
Methods
Epistemology
Rigor