Bringing Theory in (again) – Towards a theoretical approach to counter the challenges of following in Multi Sited Ethnography

- 333240
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Thirty years ago, George Marcus published a widely noted article in which he argued that ethnography must move from single-sited to multi-sited research practices in response to changes in society and social theory. Influenced particularly by postmodernist concepts and macro phenomena such as globalization and digitalization, traditional dichotomies—e.g., between lifeworld and system—have become increasingly questionable. Consequently, the analytic metaphor of following was introduced as a research strategy to better grasp complex phenomena. While this strategy has inspired valuable research, it also entails certain challenges. The most pressing issue is the problem of being “everywhere and nowhere at once,” a challenge that has primarily been approached at the level of research reflexivity.

We seek to (re)address this dilemma by introducing a theoretical approach that employs the concepts of social worlds, arenas, and processes as research heuristics. These help to structure empirical data and provide a theoretical framework MSE. Our proposal can be understood as an attempt to develop a coherent “theory–method set” consistent with the core principles of the interpretive paradigm in general and ethnography in particular.

The argument unfolds in two steps. First, we discuss the relevance of the pragmatist concept of social worlds—where social order is negotiated and action interconnected—for MSE, drawing on studies that do not explicitly identify as MSE but nevertheless follow their subjects. This demonstrates that following has been a research strategy even prior to its formal introduction into the ethnographic discourse and shows how different sites are interrelated. Second, we outline how key elements of the social worlds framework—such as boundaries, membership, (primary) activities, material effects, and spatial ligation—can help organize empirical material and guide analytical focus. The contribution concludes with a reflection on the limitations of the proposed framework, as not every research phenomenon can be conceptualized within a social world.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Otto-von-Guericke-University Magdeburg
Track
  • 3. Qualitative Research in Social Science
Keywords
Multi-sited ethnography
social worlds
trajectories
Generic processes