To cite this paper use one of the standards below:
The panel “Breaking the silence of people with disabilities in research: Inclusive methodologies and the social construction of law” aims to critically explore how qualitative research can become an inclusive, emancipatory, and politically relevant practice when co-produced with people with disabilities (PwD). It positions PwD not merely as research participants but as epistemic and political subjects whose experiential knowledge is essential to transforming how knowledge, law, and citizenship are understood and produced. The proposal departs from a dual critique: first, that qualitative research continues to reproduce exclusions by remaining anchored in biomedical and normative paradigms that silence experiential knowledge; and second, that law itself is still too often conceived as a fixed normative order rather than as a living, socially constructed field of meaning and action. Against this backdrop, the panel argues that research can and must act as a political practice capable of dismantling structural barriers, challenging ableism, and advancing epistemic justice.
Building on the experience of a panel developed at the 14th Ibero-American Congress on Qualitative Research - CIAIQ 2025 (Faria & Nunes, 2025), this proposal deepens and broadens the debate by bringing together participatory approaches, critical disability studies, and socio-legal research to strengthen strategies of active listening, recognition, and the protagonism of historically silenced groups. The panel we propose arises from the pressing need to discuss inclusive cities from the perspective of those who experience urban barriers on a daily basis. One of the key references underpinning this proposal is the article “The right to accessible cities: the perceptions and wishes of people with Down Syndrome in Brazil and Portugal” (Faria, 2024), which, based on interviews conducted in Brazil and Portugal, demonstrates the richness of the perceptions and aspirations of people with Down Syndrome regarding urban planning and accessibility practices.
The study shows that, contrary to the invisibility to which they are often subjected, these individuals have concrete proposals for designing fairer cities, reinforcing the social model of disability and the need to address not only architectural but also attitudinal and communicational barriers (Oliver, 1990; Lefebvre, 2016; WHO, 2011). The research breaks with this invisibility by investigating the perceptions and aspirations of 34 people with Down Syndrome (18 in Brazil and 16 in Portugal) regarding urban accessibility.
The results reveal individuals who reject stereotypes and demonstrate an understanding of the centrality of urban spaces in the pursuit of social justice. The relevance of listening to people with Down Syndrome in decision-making processes about inclusive cities lies in the fact that they simultaneously experience physical, communicational, and symbolic obstacles (Faria, 2024; APPACDM Coimbra, 2022). As Lefebvre (2016) underlines, if “the city is the projection of society onto space,” the conditions of circulation and permanence reveal who is truly recognised as a citizen. In the Brazilian and Portuguese contexts, the research shows that accessibility laws alone are not enough: political will and social mobilisation are necessary to make the right to the city a reality (Faria, 2024; Lefebvre, 2016).
Building upon this foundation, the panel further explores how socio-legal approaches can inform inclusive qualitative methodologies. It draws on socio-legal action research conducted within an EU-funded urban regeneration project (Nunes, 2024) that examined the emancipatory potential of urban regeneration. In this context, emancipation is understood as the liberation from conditions of authoritarianism, discrimination, or exclusion (Nunes et al., 2017), grounded in a broad conception of the absence of citizenship rights (Marshall, 1950; Costa, 2005; Santos, 2003), particularly evident in peripheral urban contexts (Balibar, 2015; Holston, 2013). This research adopted a socio-legal approach to analyse participatory processes for co-creating urban interventions. Through participant observation with significant reflexivity and secondary analysis using content analysis applied to interview transcriptions, socio-legal components were identified in terms of latencies, emergences, and resistances, contributing to a social construction that transcends abstract legal precepts.
A critical sociology of legal mobilisation is essential to rethink urban interventions that effectively address systemic inequalities. It underlines the social embeddedness of law (Villas Bôas Filho, 2019; Israël, 2012, 2020) and the expansion of juridicity (C. M. Santos, 2012), encompassing claims, resistances, and struggles against social injustice, as well as the ambivalent relations between law and contestation, reflected in repression, emotions, and revolts. By broadening the analysis of the forms of legal mobilisation, it clarifies the appropriation of law within its social construction, from a critical perspective of empowerment (Bacqué & Biewener, 2013) and through the lens of legal consciousness studies (Ewick & Silbey, 1998).
This construction considers a living law, mobilised, captured, developed, and concretised in the pursuit of a dignified life for all in the city. The experience analysed reveals both potentialities and risks, resulting in twelve conclusions for an emancipatory model of urban regeneration. This study critically examines inclusion and innovation in achieving a dignified life for all in the city. Inclusive urban regeneration fosters living, political, and economic alternatives, alongside innovative practices of action and research. The proposed emancipatory model underscores the social construction of a living law, shaped by urban action and research that reinvent social emancipation and the socio-political fabric of citizenship. In this context, professionals and researchers must namely develop mediation and intercultural skills.
The integration of inclusive participatory methodologies with socio-legal perspectives offers significant potential for methodological innovation in qualitative research. It challenges traditional paradigms by centring lived experience as a source of epistemic authority and by recognising the transformative potential of collaborative knowledge production. Such an approach has concrete implications for multiple fields, from urban planning and public policy to education, health, and justice, where co-produced, experiential knowledge can inform institutional design, policy agendas, and governance models. It also speaks directly to broader debates about democratic participation, epistemic justice, and social transformation, highlighting how inclusive research practices can reshape not only academic knowledge but also the conditions under which rights, citizenship, and social belonging are constructed.
The panel will demonstrate how different qualitative instruments can be designed, adapted, and integrated to support inclusive research practices. Through presentations that combine theoretical foundations with applied research examples, facilitators will present investigations that implemented active listening methodologies with PwD and adapted methodological protocols of legal consciousness studies within the context of action research on urban regeneration. This exchange aims to inspire practical learning while opening space for critical debate on contributions, challenges, and possibilities for further refinement of inclusive research methodologies.
In conclusion, the panel positions inclusive qualitative research as a methodological, ethical, and political project. By placing PwD and other historically marginalised groups at the centre of knowledge production, not merely as informants but as co-creators, it advances a vision of research as a living, iterative, and emancipatory practice. This vision invites researchers, practitioners, and policymakers alike to rethink their roles, to embrace methodological pluralism, and to build collaborative frameworks that can confront entrenched inequalities and enable new forms of social action. In doing so, the panel contributes not only to the development of innovative qualitative methodologies but also to the broader project of contributing to the social construction of law, fostering the social (re)construction of citizenship, and social justice in and through research.
With nearly 200,000 papers published, Galoá empowers scholars to share and discover cutting-edge research through our streamlined and accessible academic publishing platform.
Learn more about our products:
This proceedings is identified by a DOI , for use in citations or bibliographic references. Attention: this is not a DOI for the paper and as such cannot be used in Lattes to identify a particular work.
Check the link "How to cite" in the paper's page, to see how to properly cite the paper