Between opinions and meanings: exploring emotional and cognitive labour through focus groups

- 334581
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Emotional and cognitive labour refer to intangible yet routine practices that are central to organisation and functioning of family life. However, due to their practical invisibility and framing as expression of intimacy rather than socially structured form of labour, they remain difficult to access empirically.

The aim of this presentation is to offer a reflexive analysis of focus group interaction dynamics in the context of using a fictional family story as indirect elicitation technique. Six focus groups were conducted with heterosexual parents of underaged children in Croatia with the broader aim of understanding the conflicts of work and family life. Participants were asked to discuss both the fictional scenario and their own experiences of negotiation and division of cognitive and emotional responsibilities between parents.

Family life was described mainly through presentation of visible activities of household labour such as cooking or dealing with childcare, while invisible household labour remained difficult to recognize even with the story prompt. Discussion of planning or memorizing obligations, decision-making and negotiating was geared toward mutual understanding and consensus among the participants of the focus groups. The group setting of the focus groups heightened awareness of the sensitivity of this topic, prompting more socially acceptable declarations and social narratives as opposed to more personal experiences. Albeit observable, gender asymmetries were declaratively rejected, and justifications for the source of either equal or unequal distribution of invisible labour were found in the realm of personal competence, long-term experience or functional division such as scheduling differences between partners.

These results indicate that focus groups are situations of co-produced sense-making rather than neutral tools for collecting opinions and views, underscoring the necessity of careful consideration of group dynamics in research of sensitive or intimate topics such as emotional and cognitive household labour.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Department of sociology, University of Zadar
Track
  • 3. Qualitative Research in Social Science
Keywords
focus groups
group dynamics
emotional and cognitive household labour
gender research