“Transeeing the world": the theoretical and methodological challenges of a cisgender woman researching transgender visibility

- 168140
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

In a context in which experience has become credential to support what is said about the world, claimed by an irrevocable political movement for inclusion in multiple social spheres, encountering otherness is a factor to be problematised in scientific research. This paper discusses challenges of producing a thesis on the construction of transgender visibility in Brazil by a cisgender woman, and presents the theoretical-methodological strategy to deal with them.

Triangulating methods that adopt a discursive perspective, the thesis analyzed government campaigns, newspaper reports and personal accounts about the National Transgender Day of Visibility. Between February and June 2021, during the covid-19 pandemic, nine trans people (travestis, trans women, trans men) were interviewed via videoconference. Among the challenges, two required special attention: avoiding the fetishization of experiences, and preserving the intellectual authorship without appropriating the narratives. Based on the theoretical contributions of Spivak, Alcoff and Haraway and on explicit or implicit demands, feedback sessions were held in 2022. They were moments of reverent but not subservient listening. Some aspects were common: the satisfaction of being informed about the research before its publication; the manifestation of exogenous self-validation; the request for adjustments as a way of archiving memories; and the legitimization of pacts. These sessions were an effort to speak "with" them rather than speak "for" or "about" them.

In conclusion, the vantage point from which we look at trans visibility issues sets limits. Assuming that the reconstruction will never be a reflection but rather a refraction of what is seen does not reduce the expectation of the people involved to recognize their contributions in academic products. This research leads us to defend the widening of trans people's access to the production of knowledge, through political and institutional actions. As a Brazilian poet suggests, “it is necessary to transee the world”.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Universidade dos Açores
  • 2 Fundação Oswaldo Cruz
Track
  • 3. Qualitative Research in Social Science
Keywords
Gender; Transgender visibility; Otherness