Qualitative evidence in education: the emerging of a third level of research

- 167627
Paper Abstract
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Introduction: The growing production of systematic reviews has promoted a recent new form of synthesis: reviews of systematic reviews. In recent years, overviews have increased their use exponentially, but this growth has been less in education compared to other disciplines such as psychology or health overall. Goals: The aim of this study is to conduct a review of qualitative umbrella reviews in education in order to analyze trends in the topics faced in research as well as the methodology used in carrying out the studies. Methods: To detect relevant umbrella reviews in the field of education, the nine journals where educational umbrella reviews are frequently published or which title includes the words review and education were selected. The inclusion criteria are umbrella reviews conducted in educational research, peer review papers, written in English, between 2021-2023. The range time of analysis was decided because of the interest in current trends in educational research. Inductive and deductive analysis were carried out to identify themes and methodological components. Results: Only five out of 1789 articles published during that period conducted qualitative umbrella reviews. The findings reveal the prevalence of a variety of topics, such as parental involvement and student achievement; distance online learning; higher education changes and student’s coping capacity; multimedia design on learning; synthesis of educational gamification; and mapping review of research on teaching in the last fifty years. All documents present methodological quality assessment of reviews. Conclusions: This study shows a reduced number of qualitative umbrella reviews in educational research demonstrating the scarce number of systematic reviews as well. The topics faced in primary studies are diverse and there is a need to develop a consistency in the overview process with standardized tools to enable the quality assessment.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 Universidad Complutense de Madrid
Track
  • 2. Qualitative Research in Education
Keywords
overview; Qualitative Research; education