Choosing the right methodology to monitor Soil Organic Carbon (SOC) stock changes in croplands, depending on the Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) contexts, today and tomorrow

Volume 1, 2025 - 324119
Poster
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

Increasing soil organic carbon (SOC) is critical for climate change mitigation, but also food
security, biodiversity restoration, and combating land degradation. Monitoring SOC has gained
significant recognition, not only for national greenhouse gas inventories (NDCs) but also
voluntary carbon markets (VCM) and agri-environmental policies (AEPs). It has amplified the
need for accurate, continuous, and cost-effective SOC stock monitoring, at both landscape and
field levels. Traditional measure-remeasure approaches are insufficient alone to cover these
diverse needs and MRV (Monitoring, Reporting, Verification) contexts, prompting the
emergence of methodological frameworks (CIRCASA to ORCASA projects) and MRV tools
(COMET-Farm, FullCam or AgriCarbon-EO). Despite progress, practical implementation
guidelines covering the various MRV contexts remain incomplete, especially for Tier 3 modelling
approaches, which lack clarity regarding required inputs, model types, uncertainty assessment,
spatial resolution, and remote sensing integration.
This study aims to address this gap, by analysing current SOC monitoring methodologies for
croplands (Measure/Remeasure, Tier 1 to 3 modelling), proposing a decision tree to help MRV
stakeholders select the most appropriate monitoring strategy depending on their context and
highlighting the remaining limitations still to be overcome.
We assessed the current methods by their scientific robustness, but also their cost-accuracy,
scalability, and ease of implementation, to ensure both reliability and adoption. We identified key
criteria required to align monitoring approaches with current needs, and adaptation for the
future. Our analysis shows the potential of parsimonious modelling approaches assimilating

Earth Observation (EO) data, that represent key processes with few parameters while requiring
few activity data, enabling large-scale application. EO assimilation emerges as a game changer
to constraint vegetation dynamics in models, reducing the need for complex biophysical
mechanisms that require many parameters and calibration. High resolution allows to capture
intra-field variability, which is both essential for monitoring and verification.
We propose a decision tree that was adapted from the IPCC version used for NDCs, to choose
the right method for the different contexts of application (AEPs, VCM). Decision depends first on
the context of application, that defines the duration and frequency of monitoring, followed by
considerations like data availability/accuracy, existence of SOC monitoring networks, locally
parameterised models, costs and project scope.
Acknowledgements: This study was carried out in the framework of the EU ORCaSa project
(https://irc-orcasa.eu). Our special thanks go to Mathieu Nogues, Senani Karunaratne, Ben
Macdonald, Pierre Barré, Ludovic Arnaud, Rémi Cardinael, Guerric Le Maire and Patrice
Dumas.

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Institutions
  • 1 CESBIO
  • 2 CESBIO, Université de Toulouse, CNES/CNRS/INRAE/IRD/UT3
  • 3 ISRIC
  • 4 INRAE
  • 5 CIRAD
Topic
  • Measurement, monitoring, reporting, and verification: innovative methods to quantify and monitor changes in soil carbon stock using measurement, detection, and modeling technologies
Keywords
Monitoring framework
Soil organic carbon
Croplands
Carbon sequestration
Modelling