To cite this paper use one of the standards below:
This is a bibliographic comparative analysis between Brazil and the United States, focusing on Biology education, regarding the inclusion of gender and sexuality issues in curricula and pedagogical practices. This issue has evolved into a global conflict within the field of education, with significant debates occurring not only in schools but also in political spheres and the teaching of biology. We are focusing on the global 'gender wars' that influence educational policies and practices worldwide (Middleton, 2021). In Brazil, sexual education evolved from the hygienist perspective of the first half of the 20th century to biology lessons in the second half, which focused primarily on teaching about the reproductive system. Specific sexuality education initiatives were carried out sporadically by school counselors or school psychologists. From the late 1990s on, with the introduction of gender issues into academic production and the inclusion of sexual orientation as a cross curricular theme in the National Curriculum of K12 education, the incorporation of gender and sexual diversity into the curriculum advanced in the subsequent century. During the first Lula administration (2004), the Ministry of Education, in collaboration with the Ministries of Women's Policies (SEPM), Racial Equality (SEPPIR), and Human Rights (SPDDH), promoted policies for cultural diversity in schools, as well as in teacher training. In the same year, the "Brazil Without Homophobia Program" was launched, aiming to counter violence and discrimination against LGBTQ+ and promote gay citizenship. However, a transnational conservative backlash quickly emerged against the so-called "gender ideology." It involved fundamentalist Christian groups and far-right organizations that targeted schools, discredited scientific studies, and spread moral panic. Those groups sought to reverse policies that fostered women's and LGBTQ+ rights by re-naturalizing conceptions of family, motherhood, kinship, heterosexuality, and sexual difference, ultimately attempting to restore heteronormativity and male domination (Junqueira, 2017). That is why we strongly agree with Irvine (2002) for whom the “civic dialogue about sex education is one important public arena for the negotiation of sexuality, morality and citizenship”. The challenge is to encompass scientific (including biological) discourses, which are also political even in the “sciences” (Harding, 1986), about gender and sexuality. In this context, biology education has been challenged. While biology generally embraces the complexity of the nature-culture interaction perspective (Haraway, 2008), and biologists often do not theorize gender (Fausto-Sterling, 2020), there has been a growing body of knowledge about gender and sexuality in Brazilian biology education and worldwide (Maia; Carvalho, 2024). Maia & Carvalho (2024) conducted a systematic review using the descriptors "gender, sexuality, and biology education" across six databases and selected 71 texts published from 2004 to 2022. Bibliometric indicators were then conostructed. They suggest the emergence of a scientific field in biology education in Brazil starting in the early 2000s. Here we update the aforementioned review by incorporating 17 additional articles (years 2023/2024) . These studies emphasize the need for an inclusive approach to gender and sexuality in the teaching of Biology in Brazil. These researches reveal the persistence of cis-heteronormative norms, what suggests that incorporating feminist and LGBTQ+ perspectives into the curriculum is yet crucial for promoting more equitable and representative teaching. In the same way, the research on gender and sexuality in biology education in the United States reveals significant gaps in inclusivity and scientific accuracy. Our analysis of 11 articles - published from 2020 to 2024, and selected by the same methodology as in Maia and Carvalho (2024) - highlights issues such as, but not only: limited integration of multiculturalism and scientific literacy in biology standards and textbooks (Vasquez & Atwood, 2023); androcentrism and gender biases are prevalent in evolutionary biology textbooks (Jackson, Fuselier, & Eason, 2024). It calls for curricular reform to better reflect contemporary scientific and social debates. Biology classrooms present valuable opportunities to teach sex and gender-related topics more inclusively and accurately. However, current teaching paradigms often perpetuate the misconception that LGBTQ+ identities contradict “basic biology.” To address this, instructors are encouraged to adopt inclusive language, provide historical and social context, and highlight diverse role models within biology classes. These strategies can foster respect, challenge harmful misconceptions, and ultimately influence students' perspectives in research and healthcare. Zemenick et al. (2022) assert that ongoing pedagogical research is necessary to ensure that biology education evolves to maintain accuracy, inclusivity, and a more comprehensive understanding of sex, gender, and sexual diversity. Referências: FAUSTO-STERLING, Anne. Sexing the body: gender politics and the construction of sexuality. New York: Basic Books, 2020. HARAWAY, Donna. When species meet. University of Minnesota Press, 2008. HARDING, Sandra. The science question in feminism. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1986. IRVINE, Janice. Talk about sex: the battles over sex education in United States. Berkeley; Los Angeles: The University of California Press, 2002. JUNQUEIRA, Rogério Diniz. “Ideologia de gênero”: um dispositivo retórico de uma ofensiva antifeminista. In: AlfrancioFerreira Dias; Elza Ferreira Santos; Maria Helena Santana Cruz (org.). Gênero e sexualidades: entre invenções e desarticulações. Aracaju: Editora IFS, 2017. p. 47-61. JACKSON, J. Kasi; FUSELIER, Linda; EASON, Perri. Automated context analysis as a tool to compare content in sexual selection research with examples of sexual selection in evolutionary biology textbooks... Evolution: Education and Outreach, 17:3, 2024. DOI: 10.1186/s12052-024-00198-w. MAIA, Marcos; CARVALHO, Maria. Construindo a memória de um campo científico a partir de indicadores bibliométricos da produção de conhecimento em gênero e sexualidade no ensino de biologia no Brasil. Páginas a&b: arquivos e bibliotecas, 21:3, 2024. DOI: 10.21747/21836671/pag21a11. MIDDLETON, Sue. Gender wars and sexuality education in 2021: history and politics. New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies, 56, 2022. DOI: 10.1007/s40841-021-00220-5. VASQUEZ, Stacy; ATWOOD, Erin. Science for some: examining representations of relevancy and multiculturalism in Texas biology standards and textbooks. Frontiers in Education, 8:1076751, 2023. DOI: 10.3389/feduc.2023.1076751. ZEMENICK, Ash; TURNEY, Shaun; WEBSTER, Alex; JONES, Sarah; WEBER, Marjorie. Six principles for embracing gender and sexual diversity in postsecondary biology classrooms. BioScience, 72:5, 2022. DOI: 10.1093/biosci/biac013.
With nearly 200,000 papers published, Galoá empowers scholars to share and discover cutting-edge research through our streamlined and accessible academic publishing platform.
Learn more about our products:
This proceedings is identified by a DOI , for use in citations or bibliographic references. Attention: this is not a DOI for the paper and as such cannot be used in Lattes to identify a particular work.
Check the link "How to cite" in the paper's page, to see how to properly cite the paper