A Vaccine Against Fake News

- 212732
Paper-Thematic
Favorite this paper
How to cite this paper?
Abstract

A Vaccine against Fake News We are experiencing a shift in the media landscape as dramatic as the transition from oral to written storytelling. Over the last decade, the hybridization of information and entertainment into infotainment in legacy and social media, plus technical innovations from Deep Fakes to AI, have escalated the challenge of upholding ethical principles in media creation. That no audiovisual medium can now be trusted as authentic has led to a crisis in society. A Vaccine Against Fake News is developed by our group of researchers as a combined web-based and in-classroom media literacy curriculum for High school students to address the prevalence of fictional storytelling in fact-based media. Our goal is to guide students as media consumers to understand and explore the ways in which picture editors alter facts to favour story, and thereby to decipher fact from fiction in audiovisual media and content aggregators. Borrowing from real-world narrative and editing strategies in video and audio texts, our workshops enable students themselves to exercise image and sound manipulation. By pulling back the curtain to reveal key storytelling techniques, and through hands-on video editing, our approach to media literacy empowers students to manage legacy and social media. However, the responses and feedback we received after the first trial year revealed a disturbing general mistrust in all media and a questioning of any empirical facts and established science by students – the opposite of the desired outcome of our initiative. This at times vivid response is now forcing us to reevaluate both the formal approach and structure of our workshops. Our presentation explores this fundamental epistemic dilemma in teaching media literacy. Audiences need the necessary tools to distinguish fact from fiction, data from story, and evidence from narrative tropes, in fact-based media. Recent research has shown that most American youth lack the capacity to discern truth from fiction in online news-based media. In an age of fake news, disinformation has become a threat to civil societies across the globe, but is it especially problematic in Brazil. Brazil ranks first among those whose citizens said they have read and believed in fake news (2019). A study (2022) revealed about 43% of Brazilians state that they had shared false information. Data from the Functional Illiteracy Indicator (2018) indicate that about 30% of Brazil’s population aged 15 to 64 falls into the category of functional illiterates. Nevertheless, this group reports being users of digital platforms: 86% use WhatsApp, and 72% are Facebook users (2018). This population needs be to discern reliable information, identify fake news, engage autonomously and consciously in the media environment. Therefore, we hypothesized that media users lack sufficient media literacy to give them agency as consumers. However, the responses we received from participants during the pilot phase of our research study challenge this assumption. Hill defines media literacy as the viewer’s ability to analyze and respond to media with a critical distance and a degree of reflectivity about what is perceived. Thus, the study of fact-based programs needs to go beyond indexical concerns about objectivity, factuality, and truth claims. It needs to analyze spectatorship – audiences’ cognitive and affective perceptions of nonfiction’s mediated reality, in which the degree of mediation is as variable as a spectator’s awareness of it. Civil society’s challenge is to ensure that youth learn critical media literacy skills and build their capacities and knowledge to participate in democratic structures. We are interested in the complex, contingent, and context-specific ways that youth negotiate their relationship to mass media. The debate on fake news has heightened academic and, to a lesser degree, public awareness of the composed and mediated nature of television, specifically television programs that claim to give true accounts of everyday reality. As viewers become increasingly media literate, ever more aware of the tricks of the trade and constructed nature of objectivity and balance, we asked whether they will be able to build up a healthy skepticism to protect themselves from fact-based media that manipulates instead of informs, narrates instead of explains. Or will they develop a cynicism that questions or dismisses all fact-based media, whatever its source? We partnered with the Toronto District School Board (TDSB), one of the largest and most diverse school boards in North America, to ensure that the tool we developed would be relevant and accessible to a variety of cultural backgrounds. Exploring both the essential and dangerous qualities of narrative amidst hyperbolic technological change, A Vaccine Against Fake News came to draw on the insights of those who work with and think about story – picture editors. In user-determined focus groups, we asked students to create their own stories, applying specific video editing techniques. The process of creation had them describe, develop, and test the story, and thus provided educators with new strategies for teaching media literacy. Our aim for the pilot phase of our initiative was to conduct post-workshop surveys with the focus groups, review the resulting data, and then finalize an interactive, open access tool for media literacy education in high school classrooms anywhere, using browser-based dynamic media creation that allows users to create nonlinear narratives in fact-based media. The survey responses we received, however, would raise fundamental questions about the purpose of media literacy in general and our approach in particular. Barthes, R., & Duisit, L. (1975). An introduction to the structural analysis of narrative. New Literary History, 6(2), 237–272. https://doi.org/10.2307/468419 Becker, Manfred. (2022). Creating reality in factual television: The frankenbite and other fakes. New York: Routledge. Fisher, W. R. (1989). Human communication as narration: Toward a philosophy of reason, value and action (reprint edition). University South Carolina Press. Frank, A. (2010). Letting stories breathe: A socio-narratology. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Freire, P. (2000). Pedagogy of the oppressed (30th Anniversary edition). Bloomsbury Gottschall, J. (2021). The story paradox: How our love of storytelling builds societies and tears them down. Basic Books. Nichols, B. (1991). Representing reality: Issues and concepts in documentary. Indiana University Press. Salmon, C. (2017). Storytelling: Bewitching the modern mind. Verso

Share your ideas or questions with the authors!

Did you know that the greatest stimulus in scientific and cultural development is curiosity? Leave your questions or suggestions to the author!

Sign in to interact

Have a question or suggestion? Share your feedback with the authors!

Track
  • Thematic Area 12: INNOVATION REFORM IN EDUCATION FROM A GLOBAL PERSPECTIVE
Keywords
Fake News, media literacy, storytelling, editing.