Which Brazilian municipalities should be abolished? The criteria of Constitutional Amendment Bill 188/2019 applied to all 5,570 municipalities

Vol. 23, 2024 - 338957
Pôster - Envio de trabalho completo
Favoritar este trabalho
Como citar esse trabalho?
Resumo

A quarter of Brazil's municipalities hold just over 2% of the population, 6.87% of the territory and close to 10% of the Municipal Participation Fund. That this needs revising is now near-consensus; how to revise it is not. Constitutional Amendment Bill 188/2019 proposed incorporating municipalities of up to 5,000 inhabitants that could not show that the art. 156 taxes reach 10% of their revenue, and the debate settled on the fiscal test, leaving the population threshold unexamined. This article applies both criteria to all 5,570 Brazilian municipalities, combining the 2022 Census with the 2022 Annual Accounts Declarations filed with Siconfi, and reverses that order. A total of 1,286 municipalities would be affected, 23.1% of municipal units and 2.12% of the population; only 33 would prove sustainable. The fiscal test, however, is failed by 85.2% of all municipalities and by 92.5% of those between 10,001 and 20,000 inhabitants, a bracket it does not even reach; it does not separate viable from unviable ones. Nor does it measure revenue-raising effort: 746 of the 1,286 affected collect more own taxes per inhabitant than the median municipality of the bracket above, and own-source revenue per capita does not distinguish them (δ = −0.059), whereas dependence on the fund and revenue per capita separate them with large effects (δ = 0.744 and 0.811). What selects is the population threshold, and it hits the target: the affected group is the oldest in the hierarchy, 59.6% of it lost population between 2010 and 2022 and receives 2.7 times more of the fund per inhabitant. The demographic criterion is therefore the more relevant of the two, and the agenda this opens is not to abandon it but to combine it with sound measures of fiscal capacity and accessibility.

Compartilhe suas ideias ou dúvidas com os autores!

Sabia que o maior estímulo no desenvolvimento científico e cultural é a curiosidade? Deixe seus questionamentos ou sugestões para o autor!

Faça login para interagir

Tem uma dúvida ou sugestão? Compartilhe seu feedback com os autores!

Instituições
  • 1 Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo
  • 2 Universidade Estadual de Campinas (UNICAMP)
Temática
  • Migrações, Espaço e Desigualdades
Palavras-chave
Small municipalities
Fiscal federalism
Constitutional Amendment Bill 188/2019
Population ageing
Territorial reorganisation